Fishing near Caldwell in Essex County, NJ

3.55 Rating based on 15 Reviews
  • Most Caught Species: Largemouth Bass, Striped Bass, Spot, Trout, Yellow Perch, Rainbow Trout
  • # of fishing spots within 25 miles: 76
  • # of reports within 25 miles: 47
  •  
  • Discuss Caldwell area fishing in our New Jersey Fishing Forum

Caldwell Fishing Photos

Boonton Reservoir near Caldwell

Boonton Reservoir

Added by: jimbuoy
View Full Size
Mac Donalds Lake near Caldwell

Mac Donalds Lake

We've caught bass all around this lake and the one behind it [on same side of Alexander Ave - other side of Alexander Ave is private lake]
Added by: kakready
View Full Size
Oldham Pond near Caldwell

Oldham Pond

Added by: feeshinnj
View Full Size
Trout I caught at Oldham Pond near Caldwell

Trout I caught at Oldham Pond

Added by: feeshinnj
View Full Size

Top Fishing Spots near Caldwell

Whippany River
Whippany River

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 5202

Boonton Reservoir
Boonton Reservoir

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 2967

Dundee Lake
Dundee Lake

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 2788

Passaic River
Passaic River

Avg. Rating: 0
# Reviews:
Views: 3146

Columbia Lake
Columbia Lake

Avg. Rating: 4
# Reviews: 1
Views: 4326

Oldham Pond
Oldham Pond

Avg. Rating: 3
# Reviews: 1
Views: 4393

Caldwell Area Fish Species

Recent Caldwell Fishing Reports

Reservoir in North Jersey... Fishing Report Apr 19, 2009

Reservoir in North Jersey...

Reservoir in North Jersey... -

I went here at 12:30PM and didn't really think we would catch much. I was DEAD wrong!!! My third cast of the day brought in a nice Smallmouth Bass...

Avg. Rating: 4
# Reviews: 3 Views:
Review Report
Created by: jerseyjohn
Map It
Mac Donalds Lake Fishing Report Jul 18, 2009

Mac Donalds Lake

Wayne, NJ -

Nice little lake, clear water, nice bass. I've caught several every time I've gone. ...

Avg. Rating: 3
# Reviews: 2 Views:
Review Report
Created by: kakready
Map It
oldham pond Fishing Report May 22, 2011

oldham pond

haledon, NJ -

small pond...

No Reviews Views:
Review Report
Created by: dberge79
Map It
Oldham pond Fishing Report May 22, 2011

Oldham pond

haledon, NJ -

Small pond
...

No Reviews Views:
Review Report
Created by: dberge79
Map It
oldham pond Fishing Report May 22, 2011

oldham pond

haledon, NJ -

small pond...

No Reviews Views:
Review Report
Created by: dberge79
Map It
Point View Reservoir Fishing Report Jun 18, 2018

Point View Reservoir

Wayne, NJ -

Point View Reservoir is in Wayne, off Berdan Avenue. It is right behind Wayne Hills High School. At least I think it was Wayne Hills High School. Anyw...

No Reviews Views:
Review Report
Created by: jerseyjohn
Map It

Baits and Tackle used near Caldwell

Check Prices

  • power bait
  • Small gold-colored spinner and double-blade spinner with white skirt.
  • Small Gold-Colored Spinner and Double-Blade Spinner with White Skirt
  • used live eels

Soft Baits Check Prices

  • Chartreuse salamander, Senko

Live Bait (Other) Check Prices

  • netted fresh bunk er live linening and using heads. lots of bluefish on cut, mostly bass on live.
  • Chucks of spot
  • BLACK WORMS
  • Sand worms

Roundhead Jig Check Prices

  • Jighead itza-bug trailer

Minnow Check Prices

  • Live shiners, top water baits shallow crank bait. Troll in deeper water

Topwater Bait Check Prices

  • heddon Torpedo topwater

Fly (Other) Check Prices

Crankbait Check Prices

  • tried out this live target crankbait by koppers.. Wow
  • Jointed

Bass Jig Check Prices

  • Texas Rigged Worm with no weight.

Spinnerbait / Buzzbait Check Prices

  • Slow retrieve
  • I was fishing spinners all day and they were really on...
  • Number 2 spinner with slow retrieve... Got'em all day!
  • swim jigs w/trailers
  • A white Booyah pond magic

Wet Fly Check Prices

  • wollybugger,olive, conehead

Herring Check Prices

Dry Fly Check Prices

  • Emergers, Duns, and Spinners

Blade Bait Check Prices

Worm Check Prices

  • 4" Watermelon Yamamoto, Texas rigged
  • Most plastics were Texas rigged. I also use a Rapala on the rocky side of the lake.
  • Texas-Rigged Worm with bullet sinker.
  • Just bouncing a green rubber worm around the lilly pas and BAM!!

Other Check Prices

  • Fat heads
  • power bait
  • Corn
  • hot dogs
  • Marabou and Tube jigs caught YPerch Bluegills a PSeed and a LMBass.Spoons didn't work.
  • Fresh Clams

Stay Updated

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to stay updated on Caldwell fishing and other New Jersey fishing. You'll also receive community updates, invites to try new features and promotions from our partners.

NJ Fish Finder

Social Links